Adding to the very public debate over a court order demanding Apple assist the FBI in breaking into a locked iPhone and the implications it has for user security, the US House of Representatives Judiciary Committee has announced that it will call on Apple and the FBI to testify on the issue of encryption next week, on March 1.
Apple’s general counsel Bruce Sewell and FBI director James Comey are on the agenda as witnesses for the hearing, which is entitled “The encryption tightrope: balancing Americans’ security and privacy.” It is expected the committee will discuss the FBI invoking the All Writs Act of 1789 for the court order, and the implications of forcing Apple to create what could be a backdoor into locked iPhones.
Professor Susan Landau from the Worcester Polytechnic Institute and District Attorney Cyrus R Vance for the New York County will also testify as part of Apple’s panel during the hearing.
Laws vs encryption
The House Judiciary Committee is essentially in charge of overseeing the administration of justice within federal courts, administrative agencies and Federal law enforcement entities, meaning the results of this hearing could heavily influence the results of the FBI’s litigation of Apple.
“As technology companies have made great strides to enhance the security of Americans’ personal and private information, law enforcement agencies face new challenges when attempting to access encrypted information,” committee chairman Bob Goodlatte and ranking member John Conyers said in a statement.
They add that Americans have a right to strong privacy protections, and “Congress should fully examine the issue to be sure those are in place while finding ways to help law enforcement fight crime and keep us safe.”
“As we move forward, our goal is to find a solution that allows law enforcement to effectively enforce the law without harming the competitiveness of US encryption providers or the privacy protections of US citizens.”
Interestingly, in its first legal step against the FBI’s demands, Apple has today officially filed a motion to vacate the court order. Tech giants Microsoft, Facebook and Google will reportedly file motions in support of Apple as well.